Pick a Cake Flavor:
White/Vanilla
Chocolate
Sprinkles (rainbow unless otherwise specified)
Marble
Red Velvet
Carrot
Strawberry
Banana
Cinnamon
Blueberry Muffin
Coconut
Lemon

Pick a Filling/Frosting:
Buttercream (vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, lemon, raspberry, cinnamon, chocolate chip, green mint, coffee, sprinkle, pumpkin spice,
salted caramel)
Whipped Frosting -*limited availability depending on design
Fruit (raspberry, strawberry, lemon curd, blueberry)
Ganache (dark or white chocolate)
Cream Cheese Frosting
Cookies & Cream
Whipped Peanut Butter
Chocolate Mousse - *limited availability depending on design

Please contact about any other flavors not listed here...always happy to create new flavors!!

 Cake
*All Cake Prices include 3 layers of cake per tier (including sheet cakes) and any flavor/filling of your choosing.
Serving sizes listed are for "party" size portions..."wedding" size portions will increase the number of servings.
​
Smash Cakes (buttercream only)
4" cake (2 layers only)** - $35 and up
6" cake - $45 and up
Giant Cupcake - $55 and up

Single Tier Cakes
6" - $65 and up - Serves appx 12
8" - $75 and up - Serves appx 20
10" - $85 and up - Serves appx 28
12" - $95 and up - Serves appx 40

2 Tier Cakes
Mini [6" base with 4" top] - $120 and up - Serves appx 20
Standard [8" base with 6" top] - $150 and up - Serves appx 32
Large [10" base with 8" top] - $180 and up - Serves appx 48

3 Tier Cakes
Mini [8" base, 6" middle, 4" top] - $175 and up - Serves appx 40
Standard [10" base, 8" middle, 6" top] - $200 and up - Serves appx 60
Large [12" base, 10" middle, 8" top] - $250 and up - Serves appx 88

Sheet Cakes (buttercream only prices)
7"x11" - $70 and up - Serves appx 24
9"x13" - $80 and up - Serves appx 36
11"x15" - $90 and up - Serves appx 54

Each cake is custom and price will depend on the difficulty of design and requests for each individual cake. Please contact for a free quote.

All fondant used by Sugar Plum Bakery is homemade marshmallow fondant -tastes like marshmallows. We DO NOT use store bought. (*If a cake with a large amount of red or black fondant is ordered, we may make an exception and use Satin Ice brand but will inform you beforehand.)

**4" Smash Cakes can be ordered in ADDITION to a first birthday cake order over $100 for a discounted price of $15. Must be same flavor as larger cake (buttercream will be in colors that are complimentary to the larger cake).